15 Best Luxury Hotels in Key West ✔️ for Ultimate Comfort

Are you looking for the best luxury hotels in Key West to enjoy the ultimate beach holiday and splurge a little at the same time, but you don’t know where to start?

Good news: I have already done the job for you by collecting all the best luxury hotels in this travel blog. I included options that are perfect for a romantic getaway, a family holiday, or a fun vacation with your friends, but that’s not all!

All the amazing accommodations mentioned here will give you access to stunning beaches, outdoor pools, and some of Key West’s most popular attractions, and they are sorted in descending order from the most to the least expensive one.

When you find the perfect hotel for your travel needs, remember to book it immediately (or at least some months in advance) otherwise, you might lose the spot since the best rooms get booked out incredibly fast!

Are you ready to explore all the best luxury hotels in Key West with me?

Let’s jump right in!

Quick Picks for Your Stay

If you don’t have the time to read the whole post, check out this quick list of Key West’s best luxury hotels, divided by interest:

• Best luxury hotel – Sunset Key Cottages
• Top hotel for couples – H2O Suites
• Best Key West resort – Santa Maria Suites Beach Resort
• Top luxury hotel on the beach – The Capitana Key West

1. Sunset Key Cottages – for a stay on a private island

If you want to splurge during your holiday in Key West, but you don’t want to renounce privacy and tranquility, the stunning Sunset Key Cottages is for you, located on a 27-acre (11 hectares) private Island near the Florida Keys. This property hosts only 40 private cottages in total, featuring 2, 3, or 4 bedrooms, so they are perfect for both families and couples.

The hotel also gives you access to many cool facilities, like several swimming pools, a spa and wellness center, a gym, a big tennis court, a private beach to soak up some sun far from the tourist crowds, and an on-site restaurant serving a delicious complimentary breakfast every morning.

Check Availability

2. The Marquesa Hotel – for an intimate holiday

Located on Duval Street in the Key West Historic District (one of the best areas to stay in Key West), this luxury hotel is the perfect place for an intimate holiday, featuring only 44 guest rooms, all furnished with a private balcony, air conditioning, a minibar, and a private bathroom.

Here you will spend your days chilling at one of the outdoor pools, staying in shape at the fitness center, getting relaxing treatments at the on-site spa, and enjoying the many water sports available in the property surroundings, like kayaking, scuba diving, and snorkeling. Another plus? The hotel is located a very short drive from the airport, so you won’t have to worry about missing your flight!

Check Current Prices

Subscribe here to get up to 35% off your accommodation for your next trip!

3. The Gardens Hotel – with access to the best attractions

This luxury hotel, located on the popular Duval Street, offers access to some of Key West’s best attractions, like the Ernest Hemingway Home Museum and Conch Tour Train – all within walking distance from the property!

But don’t worry, the property itself has as much to offer you! Some examples? There are 2 outdoor swimming pools, a fitness center, a business center, bicycle hires, and a state-of-the-art spa offering relaxing massages and concierge services. If you choose to stay here, make sure you don’t miss the live music every Sunday in the property gardens.

Find Available Dates

4. Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages – for a tranquil holiday

If you are looking for a place where to have a tranquil holiday in Key West, this luxury hotel is for you, offering a laid-back environment in a quiet location without any noise, being at the same time a few steps from Duval Street and the beautiful South Beach.

Here the guest rooms are spacious and cozy, all offering a private balcony or patio surrounded by green palms and offering direct access to a big swimming pool. But what guests love the most about the property is the complimentary poolside happy hour available every evening, and the delicious hot breakfast served daily, with a wide variety of food to choose from.

Check Availability

5. H2O Suites – the TOP adults-only resort

Located in Key West’s Old Town, within walking distance from some of the most popular attractions and beaches in the area, this adults-only resort is perfect for those who want to have a romantic getaway far from the noise of kids, offering 22 one-bedroom suites.

In this Keys resort, each suite comes with its own private balcony or patio, 2 flat-screen TVs, a living room area, free Wi-Fi, and a private bathroom with a spa tub and rainfall shower, perfect for enjoying some intimate moments with your special one. And if you ever want to leave your accommodation, you can rent scooters and bikes to explore the surroundings, relax in the rooftop pool, have a nightly happy hour at the on-site bar, or stay in shape at the fitness center.

Check Current Prices

6. The Capitana Key West – for breathtaking sea views

This Key West luxury hotel faces the beach and offers stunning guest rooms with a private terrace or patio, from where you can enjoy breathtaking views of the sea at any time of the day… imagine waking up like that!

Here you will have access to facilities for literally any taste, like a beautiful private beach, an outdoor swimming pool and hot tub, a business center, a fitness center to stay in shape, a cool terrace if you just want to chill or soak up some sun, and a restaurant on-site to enjoy some delicious meals.

Find Available Dates

7. Santa Maria Suites Beach Resort – the best service

Located within a few blocks of the Southernmost Point Buoy of the continental USA, this Key West resort offers a super friendly and helpful service. The staff will welcome you with free ice cream at the moment of your check-in.

A stay in this luxury resort will include towels to use at the 2 swimming pools, beach chairs, and umbrellas at the private beach, complimentary bottled water, fresh fruit and smoothies, delicious daily treats like fresh-baked muffins and candies, and access to a 24h concierge service.

Check Availability

8. Hyatt Residence Club Key West – for families

This amazing beach resort in Key West is perfect for a family holiday, offering fun activities for any age and taste, like snorkeling, windsurfing, and fishing in the property’s surroundings, plus a big outdoor pool, a hot tub, and a fitness center.

And wait to see the spacious rooms, hosting up to 6 people and coming with a fully equipped kitchen, a separate dining room, a private screened-in balcony, and guest rooms with flat-screen TVs. Here you will feel at home away from home, and you’ll be able to enjoy some intimate moments with your special ones. Check it out!

Find Available Dates

9. Oceans Edge Key West – the best pools

Do you love pools? Then you will love this luxury hotel in Key West, featuring not one, but six swimming pools, as well as a waterfront bar for some cool aperitifs, a delicious restaurant for the best candlelight dinners, a fitness center, a paddle shop, onsite watersports, and a 165-slip marina.

And wait to see the stunning guest rooms! They all come with panoramic ocean views, a private balcony or patio where you can sit and enjoy the fresh sea breeze, a private bathroom stocked with free toiletries and a hairdryer, a flat-screen TV, and a separate living space! Another plus? The hotel is only 15 minutes walking from Duval Street, so you can reach all its attractions in the blink of an eye, like the Nature Conservatory and the Key West Aquarium.

Check Availability

10. The Marker Key West Harbor Resort – top entertainment

Are you the type of traveler who wants to join as many activities as possible during your holiday? Then check out this Key West resort, offering access to cool water sports like diving, snorkeling, and fishing, and daily activities such as games, aqua yoga in the outdoor pool, and workouts classes at the fitness center – you will be entertained from when you wake up until late at night!

And wait to see the beautiful rooms which have king or double queen beds, large bathrooms with rain showers and separate soaking tubs, free Wi-Fi, a private terrace, and access to a private valet parking, perfect if you have your own car and you want to explore the other parts of the Florida Keys in your free time.

Check Current Prices

11. Ocean Key Resort & Spa – for a TOP location

The Ocean Key Resort & Spa has one of the TOP locations in Key West, right at the end of Duval Street (where you’ll find the city’s top entertainment and dining options), with direct access to the famous Sunset Pier and Mallory Square, and just steps away to the Gulf of Mexico at the same time!

But this Key West resort has much more to offer than a good location, starting from a wide variety of kids’ programs (perfect if you’re traveling with the family) to world-class gourmet dining at the on-site restaurant and relaxing treatments at the full-service spa. I recommend choosing the couple’s massage if you want to have the ultimate romantic experience!

Find Available Dates

12. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West – top hotel on Stock Island

The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is located on the beautiful Stock Island, the best island in the Florida Keys if you’re looking for a local feel, and features a beautiful waterfront swimming pool with private cabanas, two delicious restaurants on-site, access to cool water sports, a fitness center, and a business center

And if this isn’t enough, this luxury hotel offers amazing guest rooms and studios with great views over the water or park – some of them even come with outdoor showers, pull-out sofas, and large porches. They are pet-friendly, so you can bring your four-legged friend with you!

Check Current Prices

13. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa – for foodies

Are you a foodie like me? Then you will love this Key West resort, known for the fresh seafood served in the 2 restaurants on-site: the Shor American Seafood Grill and Blue Mojito Pool Bar – both extremely delicious!

But here, you can do way more than just eat. Spend the day on fun activities like scuba diving, snorkeling, and jet skiing (check out the jet ski island tour if you want to explore the surrounding area from the water!), and get relaxing massages, facials, and body treatments at the on-site spa, or stay in shape at the fitness center.

NOTE: This hotel is rated a little lower than what I would usually recommend for tourists, but it still makes a great option to include it in this list of top hotels to stay in Key West.

Check Current Prices

14. Parrot Key Hotel & Villas – for natural surroundings

If you just want to disconnect from the outside world during your holiday in Key West, the intimate Parrot Key Hotel & Villas is for you, nestled along Florida Bay (a short drive away from Old Town), and surrounded by lush gardens, green landscapes, and picturesque palm trees.

Here you can spend your days chilling at one of the several swimming pools, joining cool activities in the property’s surroundings like kayaking, treating yourself with an on-site massage at the on-site wellness center, or take a free complimentary shuttle from the hotel to the city center and go exploring its restaurants, museums, shops, and bars.

NOTE: This hotel is rated a little lower than what I would usually recommend for tourists, but I decided to include it in this list to give you enough options of places to stay in Key West.

Check Current Prices

15. Pier House Resort & Spa – best private beach

Located on a beautiful private beach, the Pier House Resort & Spa is the perfect place to enjoy some deserved relaxation, hosting a state of art spa featuring massages, facials, couples’ appointments, and even pedicures, manicures, haircuts, waxing, etc., as well as a whirlpool hot tub and outdoor swimming pool.

And wait to see the rooms: here, you can choose from a wide variety of accommodations, from regular rooms to spa suites, one and two-bedroom suites, accessible rooms, and a presidential suite for the ultimate romantic getaway! The resort also offers a very convenient location to explore Key West, within walking distance to most of downtown.

NOTE: Pier House Resort & Spa is rated a little lower than what we usually recommend for tourists, but it still makes a very good option for a stay in Key West, so I decided to include it in this list!

Check Current Prices

🛎️ Best luxury hotel in Key West:	Sunset Key Cottages
👩‍❤‍👨 Best honeymoon hotel:	H2O Suites
🌊 Top hotel with a view:	The Capitana Key West
🏖️ Hotel with a private beach:	Santa Maria Suites Beach Resort
💵 Avg hotel price in Key West:	US$600

FAQs about the best luxury hotels in Key West

Conclusion

Here we are at the end of this useful travel guide about the best luxury hotels in Key West. We saw accommodation options for any kind of taste: properties on a private beach, family-friendly resorts, and adults-only hotels for a romantic getaway.

If you still haven’t decided where to stay, no worries. Below you will find my 2 absolute favorite hotels in Key West:

• Sunset Key Cottages – This luxury hotel in Key West is located on a 27-acre (11 hectares) private Island near the Florida Keys and hosts only 40 private cottages in total!
• Ocean Key Resort & Spa – Has the perfect location at the end of Duval Street and is close to the famous Sunset Pier and Mallory Square.

If you like them as much as I do, then book them immediately or at least some months in advance, so you can reserve yourself a spot and maybe also take advantage of some good deals.

And if you have any questions or hotel suggestions for me, please don’t hesitate to share them in the comments below… I’m looking forward to reading them all!

Have an amazing holiday in Key West!

Elena

---